When you walk into Fusaro’s Pizza and Pasta in Manahawkin, you’re not just getting great food—you’re experiencing what generations of Italian tradition can create. Our customers have spoken, and their favorites tell a story of authentic flavors, quality ingredients, and the kind of comfort food that keeps families coming back.
From our signature Meatball Vodka Pizza to our beloved Grandma slices, these dishes represent the heart of what makes Fusaro’s a local favorite. Let’s explore the menu items that have earned a special place in our community’s hearts.
Customer Favorites That Keep Them Coming Back
Meatball Vodka Pizza: A Perfect Marriage of Flavors
Our Meatball Vodka Pizza stands as one of our most requested specialty pies, and it’s easy to see why. This masterpiece features our homemade meatballs, sliced thin and perfectly distributed across a creamy vodka sauce base. The result is a rich, satisfying pizza that combines the comfort of traditional meatballs with the elegant sophistication of vodka sauce.
As one customer raved, “The meatball vodka pie was absolutely perfect—thick cheese, not greasy, and the vodka sauce was delicious! The thin sliced meatballs were the perfect topping.”
Chicken Fingers & Fries: Simple Perfection
Sometimes the best dishes are the simplest ones. Our Chicken Fingers & Fries deliver exactly what you’d expect—crispy, golden chicken fingers paired with perfectly seasoned fries. It’s a crowd-pleaser that works for kids and adults alike.
This dish has become particularly popular with families, offering something everyone can enjoy. The chicken is tender on the inside with that satisfying crunch on the outside, while our fries provide the perfect salty complement.
Grandma Slices: Tradition in Every Bite
Our Grandma slices represent the essence of traditional Italian-American pizza. These square slices feature a thin, fluffy center with a wonderfully crispy bottom, topped with our tangy tomato sauce that lets the quality of our ingredients shine through.
Multiple customers have specifically mentioned Grandma pizza in their reviews, with one noting it as a “recommended dish.” This traditional style pizza connects our customers to authentic flavors while delivering the comfort food experience they’re seeking.
Buffalo Chicken Pizza: Bold and Flavorful
For those who like a little heat, our Buffalo Chicken Pizza delivers perfectly balanced spice. Made with grilled chicken, our special buffalo sauce, and melted mozzarella cheese, this specialty pie offers just the right amount of kick without overwhelming your taste buds.
The combination of tender grilled chicken and tangy buffalo sauce creates a pizza that satisfies those craving something with more personality than your standard pie.
“Fusaro Favorites”: Our Signature Specialty
Our rotating selection of “Fusaro Favorites” keeps things exciting for our regular customers. These unique specialty pizzas showcase our creativity and commitment to bringing new flavors to the table while maintaining the quality standards our customers expect.
This ever-changing selection means there’s always something new to try, keeping even our most loyal customers curious about their next visit.
What Our Customers Are Saying
The love our community shows Fusaro’s Pizza & Pasta speaks volumes about what we’ve built here in Manahawkin, NJ. Here’s what locals are saying about their favorite dishes:
Rosie P. shared: “Sometimes mid week you just need to order a thin grandma vodka pizza with some calamari to get you through the rest of the week. The best part is that it was still hot and fresh when it was delivered. Delivery service is always on time and whether you order online or over the phone it’s super easy, but online offers coupons you can apply to your order. My family and I love their pizza, but this is definitely our favorite.”
Dan D. noted: “This is our local spot for pizza, wings, cheesesteaks, and burgers. Whenever we order out, we get Fusaro’s. For years, we’ve been consistently happy with the food we’ve gotten and the service we’ve received. It’s a great thing to be able to support a local business AND get food we love. Delivery is always quick, the food is always hot, and it’s brought with a smile and a great attitude. If you want pizza tonight, get it from these folks…you’ll be happy..”
Antonette B. praised our variety: “Great food! Got margarita pizza, calzone and chicken parm dinner and all three exceeded our expectations. Would highly recommend this place, this will be my only spot for Italian food! .”
Ed S. stated: “Best pizza in town. I’ve had pizza in every pizzeria in Manahawkin and Barneget. Some are really good but this place is definitely the best pizza in town.”
Best Fusaro’s Pizza & Pasta Menu Items Loved by Manahawkin Locals
These customer favorites represent more than just popular menu items—they showcase our commitment to authentic Italian flavors, quality ingredients, and the kind of exceptional service that builds lasting relationships with our community.
Whether you’re craving the rich comfort of our Meatball Vodka Pizza, the traditional appeal of our Grandma slices, or want to try one of our rotating “Fusaro Favorites,” each dish reflects our family’s dedication to bringing you the best pizza Manahawkin has to offer.
Ready to taste what locals love? Visit us at 31 N Main St in Manahawkin, call (609) 978-3888, or order online to experience these customer favorites for yourself. Join the growing list of satisfied customers who’ve made Fusaro’s their go-to spot for authentic Italian flavors and exceptional pizza.
