There is something undeniably special about the perfect slice of pizza. It isn’t just about the melted cheese or the tangy sauce; it’s about the memories created around the table. At Fusaro’s Pizza & Pasta, the premier destination for Manahawkin pizza, we believe that great food brings people together. Whether you are grabbing a quick lunch or settling in for a family dinner, we are dedicated to serving authentic Italian flavors that transport you straight to Naples.
While we are proud of our entire menu, our brick oven pizzas are the heart and soul of our kitchen. We combine traditional recipes passed down through generations with fresh, local ingredients to create crispy, flavorful, and unforgettable pies. If you are searching for the best brick oven pizza NJ has to offer, you’ve found it right here on the Jersey Shore.
We are taking a closer look at the signature pies that keep our customers coming back for more. From the spicy-sweet kick of the Lucy Special to the creamy indulgence of our Vodka Pie, here is exactly what you need to order for your next pizza delivery in Manahawkin.
Story Behind Fusaro’s: Authentic Italian Roots
To understand why we take our pizza so seriously, you have to understand where we come from. Our roots go back to Fusaro, a small, picturesque town in the Phlegraean Fields outside of Naples, Italy. Pizza there is a way of life, not just a convenience food.
In the 1980s, my father brought that passion for authentic Italian cuisine to the United States. He sought new opportunities, but refused to leave his traditions behind. Over 35 years ago, he opened Naples Pizzeria in Barnegat, establishing a standard for quality that the local community quickly embraced.
Growing up in the business, I learned the craft from the ground up. I watched, listened, and worked alongside family and friends to master the art of dough, sauce, and service. Fusaro’s Pizza & Pasta is the evolution of that journey. We honor the legacy of Naples Pizzeria while bringing a fresh, modern approach to Manahawkin Italian restaurants. Every pie we bake is a tribute to those decades of experience and a promise of quality to our customers.
Signature Pizzas You Can’t Miss
Our menu features a wide array of options, but a few standout stars have earned a permanent spot in the hearts of our regulars. If you are looking to branch out from a standard plain cheese pie, these are the signature creations you need to try.
Lucy Special
If you love a balance of savory, spicy, and sweet, the Lucy Special is designed for you. This pie starts with our signature crispy crust and is topped with savory pepperoni and dollops of creamy ricotta cheese. But the real magic comes from the finishing touches: a dusting of red pepper flakes and a drizzle of Zab’s Hot Honey.
The heat from the pepper flakes and the hot honey cuts through the richness of the ricotta and pepperoni, creating a flavor profile that is complex and addictive. It is a modern twist on classic toppings that has quickly become a fan favorite for anyone seeking unique pizza in Ocean County.
Vodka Pie
Vodka sauce is a staple of Italian-American cuisine, and at Fusaro’s, we do it right. Our Vodka Pie swaps out traditional marinara for our rich, homemade vodka sauce. You can order this on any crust, but it truly shines when paired with the right toppings.
Many of our customers rave about adding meatballs to this pie. As one happy customer, noted in a review: “The meatball vodka pie was absolutely perfect – thick cheese, not greasy, and the vodka sauce was delicious! The thin sliced meatballs were the perfect topping.”
Whether you keep it plain to savor the creamy sauce or load it up with thin-sliced meatballs, this pie offers a comforting, velvety texture that stands apart from other Manahawkin pizza options.
Sicilian Pizza
Sometimes, you just need a substantial slice. Our Sicilian Pizza is a nod to the traditional square pies of Sicily. Unlike a standard round pie, the Sicilian features a thick, airy crust that is crisp on the bottom and soft in the middle.
We top it with our signature sauce and plenty of mozzarella. The dough is allowed to rise in the pan, giving it that characteristic sponge-like texture that soaks up the flavor of the sauce without becoming soggy. It is the perfect choice for feeding a hungry crowd or for anyone who prefers a heartier bite when ordering pizza takeout in Manahawkin.
Grandma Pizza
While it is also square, the Grandma Pizza is a completely different experience from the Sicilian. This pie is a tribute to the kind of pizza Italian grandmothers would make at home—simple, rustic, and bursting with flavor.
The Grandma crust is significantly thinner than the Sicilian. It is baked in a pan coated with olive oil, which “fries” the bottom of the crust to a perfect golden crunch. We top it with crushed plum tomatoes, fresh garlic, mozzarella, and fresh basil. The sauce is typically layered over the cheese, preventing the dough from getting soggy and ensuring every bite is crisp. It is a lighter, garlic-forward option that highlights the quality of our ingredients.
More Than Just Pizza: Full Italian Menu
While our brick ovens are the centerpiece of the kitchen, Fusaro’s offers a full culinary experience. We are committed to using fresh, local ingredients across our entire menu, making us one of the top Italian restaurants in Manahawkin.
If you are in the mood for pasta, our Penne Vodka is a must-try, featuring the same beloved sauce found on our pizza. We also offer classic entrees like Chicken Parmigiana and Eggplant Rollatini, all served with salad and dinner rolls.
For a more casual lunch, our Subs and Wraps are packed with flavor. The Buffalo Chicken options are particularly popular. As one customer mentioned, “The buffalo chicken slices were awesome and full of flavor and crunchy.” You can get that same flavor profile in a wrap or a sub, making it easy to enjoy on the go.
Ordering and Community in Manahawkin
We want to make it as easy as possible for you to enjoy a great meal. We offer convenient online ordering for both pickup and delivery. You can browse our full menu, customize your pizza, and have it delivered piping hot to your doorstep in Manahawkin, Stafford Township, and the surrounding Jersey Shore areas.
We also invite you to join our community by signing up for our monthly newsletter. It is the best way to get exclusive offers, stay updated on new menu items, and receive insider updates about what is happening at the restaurant.
Above all, we love seeing our customers. Our dining room is a space where friends and neighbors can gather. We strive to provide a welcoming, spotless setting where you can relax and enjoy genuine Italian hospitality.
Signature Brick Oven Pizzas in Manahawkin, NJ – Fusaro’s Pizza
At Fusaro’s Pizza & Pasta, we are driven by a simple philosophy: honor tradition, serve quality, and treat every customer like family. Whether you are trying the hot honey kick of the Lucy Special or the rustic crunch of a Grandma pie, we put passion into every step of the process.
We invite you to stop by our location on North Main Street or order online tonight. Taste the history, enjoy the fresh ingredients, and find out why locals choose Fusaro’s when searching for the best pizza in Manahawkin. Don’t forget to snap a photo of your favorite slice and tag us on social media. We love seeing which pie you pick!
