Pizza Delivery in Manahawkin, NJ

After a long day at the beach or a busy workday, nothing hits the spot quite like a hot, fresh pizza delivered right to your door. For Manahawkin residents and Jersey Shore visitors, the choice is clear: Fusaro’s Pizza & Pasta has been proudly serving the community with reliable, delicious delivery since 2010.

When you’re craving authentic flavor without the fuss, we bring the best of the Shore directly to you. Here’s why Fusaro’s is the top choice for pizza delivery in the area.

Local Roots, Local Trust

Since opening our doors, Fusaro’s Pizza has become a beloved part of the Manahawkin community. We aren’t just another pizza place; we’re your neighbors. As the first of our kind in Manahawkin, Fusaro’s offers a one-of-a-kind pizza experience you won’t find anywhere else. Our story is deeply woven into the fabric of the Jersey Shore, with family traditions that stretch back to Fusaro, Italy. This connection to our home inspires us to serve food we’re proud of, earning the trust of local families year after year.

Unlike national chains, ordering from Fusaro’s means you’re supporting a local business that cares about its customers. When you get a delivery from us, you’re getting more than just a meal—you’re getting a taste of local tradition.

Our Classic Pies

At Fusaro’s, we take pride in offering a variety of classic pies, each crafted with care and rooted in tradition. Here’s a closer look at our signature offerings:

Traditional Round Plain

A timeless favorite made with our traditional New York-New Jersey pizza dough. We use a blend with non-bleached, non-bromated flour, mixed and balled fresh daily before going into the fridge. This process creates a healthier, more digestible pizza with a thin crust and a thicker end for the perfect balance of texture. Simple, classic, and absolutely delicious, our pizza is baked to achieve its signature texture and flavor.

Deep Dish Round Pan Pizzas

For those who love a heartier option, our pan pizza dough is crafted using a blend of Italian flours. After proofing for 24 hours at room temperature, the dough is stretched into olive-oiled pans and left to proof for another 24 hours. The result? A thick, airy, flaky crust that’s crispy outside, light on the inside, and incredibly digestible—a perfect base for all your favorite toppings.

Square Grandma

This beloved pie uses the same Italian flour blend as our pan pizzas and proofs for at least two days in the fridge. After being stretched and prepped with olive oil, oregano, Parmesan, and shredded mozzarella, it proofs again to achieve its signature thin, fluffy center and perfectly crispy bottom. Light, flavorful, and easy to digest, this pizza is a textural delight.

Sicilian Pizza Squares

Made with our Italian flour blend, this dough is balled and rested in the fridge for a minimum of two to three days to enhance both flavor and digestibility. After proofing, we bake the shells to achieve a thick, fluffy center with a satisfyingly crispy bottom and soft, pillowy interior. It’s a bold, hearty option, offering a perfectly balanced crunch and softness that elevates every bite.

Personal Gluten-Free & Cauliflower Pizza

We believe everyone deserves to enjoy great pizza, which is why we offer personal-sized options that cater to specific dietary needs. Our gluten-free and cauliflower crust pizzas are crafted with care, delivering the same delicious flavors in every bite.

Each pie is made with fresh, high-quality ingredients and served with a touch of Fusaro’s tradition, ensuring every slice feels like home.

Salads and Sides

Each pie is made with fresh, high-quality ingredients and served with a touch of Fusaro’s tradition, ensuring every slice feels like home.

Quality That Travels Well

A great delivery pizza starts with incredible ingredients and ends with a perfect arrival. We begin with our expertly crafted doughs—from traditional New York style to Sicilian—made with premium flours and perfected through generations of experience. We top our pizzas with the best cheeses and locally sourced ingredients, including fresh Jersey tomatoes when they’re in season. Fusaro’s proudly serves the Manahawkin community by offering a diverse menu that caters to both residents and visitors, ensuring there’s something for everyone.

We take extra care in packaging every order to ensure your food arrives hot, fresh, and ready to enjoy. Our specialty pies, hearty pasta trays, and crispy wings are designed to hold up perfectly, so your meal is just as delicious at your dining table as it is in our kitchen.

Convenience for Locals & Vacationers

Life in a shore town is all about balancing work, play, and relaxation.

For Manahawkin residents, we’re the perfect solution for easy weeknight dinners, family pizza nights, or catering a gathering without leaving home. For visitors enjoying the Jersey Shore, we take the stress out of mealtime after a long day in the sun. Instead of worrying about cooking at the rental, let us handle dinner. Ordering is simple; just give us a call or place your order online for fast, hassle-free delivery. Fusaro’s is open for delivery, making it easy for both locals and visitors to enjoy a great meal whenever they need it.

Options for Every Crowd

Whether you’re feeding your family or a house full of beach guests, our menu has something for everyone. We offer a wide range of pizzas, including classic rounds, Grandma pies, Sicilian style, and gluten-free options. Our specialty pies, like the Fusaro Special or the Chicken Bacon Ranch, are local favorites, and our Lucy Special stands out as a must-try for pizza lovers.

But we don’t stop at pizza. Our menu includes classic pasta dishes, delicious subs, fresh salads, and shareable appetizer trays perfect for larger groups. Fries are a popular side to complete your meal. Select pasta and seafood dishes feature shrimp for extra flavor and variety. No matter the occasion, a family gathering, a beach house party, or a game night, Fusaro’s has you covered. Customers love to eat at Fusaro’s because the food is always worth it.

Reliable, Friendly Service

We pride ourselves on providing dependable pizza delivery service throughout Manahawkin. Our drivers know the community and are committed to getting your food to you on time. As one customer, Zach B., put it, “Just ordered a couple trays for our family beach week and couldn’t ask for better service! So nice to be treated like a regular even though this was my first experience! Highly recommend and great location right off the highway!” That’s the standard we strive for with every single order.

Community Involvement

Fusaro Pizza And Pasta isn’t just a restaurant, we’re a proud member of the Manahawkin community. We are dedicated to creating a warm, welcoming atmosphere both inside our pizzeria and throughout the area. We love supporting local events, sponsoring area teams, and finding new ways to give back to the community that has embraced us. Whether you’re a longtime resident or just visiting the Jersey Shore, you’ll feel right at home at Fusaro’s. We believe in the power of great food to bring people together, and we’re committed to making a positive impact in our neighborhood. Join us for a delicious meal and experience the best of Jersey hospitality, served with a smile.

Catering Services

Planning an event in Manahawkin or the surrounding area? Let Fusaro Pizza And Pasta take care of the food with our catering services. Our menu features a wide selection of pasta dishes, pizzas, salads, and sides; perfect for any occasion, from family gatherings to corporate events. We work closely with you to create a customized menu that fits your needs, including options for dietary preferences and restrictions. Our team handles everything, offering delivery and setup to make your event stress-free and delicious. Whether you’re hosting a birthday, wedding, or business meeting, our pizzeria is ready to serve up great food and exceptional service. Contact us today to learn more about our catering options and let us help make your next event a memorable one!

Next time you’re in Manahawkin, let Fusaro’s bring the taste of the Jersey Shore to your door. With our deep local roots, commitment to fresh ingredients, and reliable service, we’re confident we’ll become your go-to for pizza delivery. For those seeking something special, Fusaro’s also offers select pasta dishes with a delicate white wine sauce that enhances the elegance and flavor of your meal.

Ready for a delicious meal? Order online now or give us a call at (609) 978-3888 to place your delivery order.